The crypto industry recently underwent a significant development as Coinbase, one of the leading crypto exchanges, announced its decision to cease token staking services for users in four American states – California, New Jersey, South Carolina, and Wisconsin. The action was taken in response to a lawsuit by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which alleges that Coinbase’s retail staking services are deemed securities under the law.
Following this suit, securities regulators in ten states initiated their own proceedings against Coinbase. Four of them even issued preliminary orders to the company, requiring it to limit its staking services in their jurisdictions. Despite these events, Coinbase remains resolute, pledging to fight the charges and uphold the access to staking services for all.
Understanding Staking and Its Significance
Staking has become an integral part of the cryptocurrency industry. It involves pledging cryptocurrencies as collateral to earn additional tokens while contributing to the security of a blockchain network. In Coinbase’s case, it offers staking for 90 digital assets through its Earn program, with yields reaching as high as 10%, paid out in the networks’ native tokens.
The growth of staking has been substantial, with the cumulative value of all staked assets rising to $68 billion at the end of Q2, marking a 61% increase from the previous quarter. Moreover, liquid staking – a recent construct allowing investors to continue using their tokens while they are staked – accounts for a growing portion of the market.
Regulatory Landscape Under SEC’s Leadership
The SEC’s approach to regulating the crypto industry has been perceived as antagonistic by industry participants. They feel the agency is not willing to engage with the crypto industry in good faith. Coinbase is not the first crypto exchange to fall under the regulatory radar for its staking product; earlier this year, Kraken had to cease its staking services following a $30 million settlement with the SEC.
Deciphering Coinbase’s Business Model
Staking is a significant revenue stream for Coinbase. In Q1 alone, it generated $73.7 million, accounting for 9.5% of the company’s total revenue. The company’s main sales still come from trading fees, which comprises 49%, but this is down from 87% a year earlier, highlighting Coinbase’s efforts to diversify its revenue streams amidst increasing exchange competition and trading fee compression.
Coinbase’s share performance has been robust, with a considerable boost coming from Ripple’s recent partial court victory in its own suit by the SEC. The ruling – that cryptocurrency transactions are not always necessarily sales of securities – may be appealed and is not binding on other courts, but it has momentarily safeguarded Coinbase’s core business model.
The Future of Liquid Staking and the Dominance of Lido
Boris Revsin, Managing Partner at Tribe Capital, offers a promising outlook on the future of liquid staking. He believes the growing user experience for liquid staking will eventually lead to more cold storage and institutional ETH being staked off centralized exchanges. His optimism extends to Lido, currently the front-runner across all key metrics, as he expects the entire market to grow and Lido to retain the largest market share.
Coinbase’s staking program is a considerable player in the ether liquid-staking market, with Lido holding the lion’s share. Even though decentralized platforms like Lido offer a certain allure, they bring their own set of risks. In the event of code bugs or emerging exploits, user funds might be in jeopardy.
Investors’ Dilemma: The Tradeoffs of Staking Options
Investors seeking to stake their assets face a challenging decision between centralized staking, liquid-staking protocols, and running their own validator nodes. While each option has its advantages and risks, the fate of Coinbase’s staking services might influence the preferences of unsophisticated retail investors, who are attracted by its convenience and ease of use.
Legal Battles and Their Repercussions on the Crypto Industry
Coinbase’s legal disputes with state regulators and the SEC have far-reaching implications not only for its shares but also for the broader crypto industry. The outcomes could set precedents on which types of assets and products should be classified as securities. The SEC has already identified several tokens as such in its lawsuit against Coinbase.
Final Reflection
As we step into a world intertwined with blockchain and cryptocurrencies, we must remember that the pursuit of financial evolution shouldn’t compromise the principles of liberty and self-sovereignty that form the bedrock of our society. In navigating these tumultuous waters, it is essential to protect the right to transact freely without sacrificing our rights to financial privacy and autonomy.
Sources:
Recent Stories
